Second order thinking
How AI-powered answers are rewriting the rules for professional services marketers, and how to stay visible
Imagine a potential client searching for an area of expertise that your organisation specialises in.
The search engine delivers an instant, AI-generated answer, but your name isn’t mentioned. Or worse, it attributes the insight to someone else.
This isn’t a thought experiment. It’s happening right now.
We’ve entered the "Age of Answers". A world where audiences no longer search, they ask.
Where clicks give way to conversations, and AI-powered overviews deliver the information directly on the results page. For professional services organisations built on visibility, reputation, and expertise, that’s a profound change.
But it’s also a rare opportunity to get ahead.
The shift you can’t afford to ignore
For two decades, the digital marketing playbook was clear: produce quality content, optimise for search, and let the clicks follow.
That model is breaking down.
According to Datos (part of SEMrush), 58.5% of Google searches in the U.S. now end without a click. In Europe, it’s closer to 60%. And as AI overviews roll out, those numbers will only increase.
More than
SEMRush
of searches result in no click through to the originating website.
Our own analysis across professional services clients shows organic search referrals down by more than 25% year-on-year, even before the full rollout of Google’s AI overviews.
Instead of ten blue links, users are served summaries, knowledge panels, and AI-generated insights, often without ever visiting a site.
Meanwhile, answer engines like ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity are making tens of thousands of content requests for every single click-through. Your content might already be informing their answers. But without clear structure, your brand may not be credited at all.
Visibility no longer starts at your website
Your expertise now appears in places your website doesn’t reach:
- AI-generated answers and chat interfaces
- Knowledge panels and overviews
- Industry platforms and data aggregators
That means visibility now depends on how readable your content is to machines as well as humans.
Google’s E-E-A-T framework:
- Experience
- Expertise
- Authority
- Trust
now underpins not only rankings but also how AI systems decide what to cite.
Structured, well-sourced content with clear context is more likely to appear in those answers, even when no click occurs.
The new rule:
Write for humans. Structure for AI.
What smart marketers are doing differently
Zero-click search isn’t a passing trend. It’s the new normal.
The organisations adapting early are the ones maintaining visibility and in some cases, gaining it.
Here’s where to start:
1. Make your content readable - for machines
Add schema markup at every level:
- Site level – organisation, logo, contact, locations
- Template level – services, articles, case studies, bios
- Content level – quotes, videos, testimonials
This gives AI systems a complete, machine-readable picture of who you are and what you do. It’s UX for AI - ensuring your content is interpreted correctly, not just indexed.
2. Feed the machines with structured content
AI craves clarity and context. Repurpose existing content into formats it can easily cite:
- FAQs, How-Tos and Q&As
- Structured testimonials and case studies
- Short TL;DR summaries for long-form content
Create a simple llms.txt file to guide AI crawlers. Think of it as an AI sitemap that introduces your organisation, audiences, and expertise.
3. Measure what matters
Pageviews are no longer a proxy for success.
Track engagement, AI referrals, and brand citations instead of clicks.
In early pilots, AI-referred visitors converted 3–5 times more often than traditional organic search traffic.
What about lead generation?
Yes - traffic will fall. But trust and recognition can rise.
Being cited in an AI-generated answer builds credibility at the very start of a prospect’s journey, often before they’re even "in market".
In professional services, that early credibility compounds. When someone finally does click, they already trust your expertise.
Visibility isn’t just about being seen - it’s about being trusted enough to be cited.
Turning disruption into advantage
This is not the death of marketing, it’s the end of an old operating model.
Just as mobile, social and content marketing reshaped discovery in past decades, the AI era demands a new foundation.
Those foundations are simple:
- Make your expertise readable.
- Teach AI who you are.
- Show up with originality.
- Keep adapting.
Organisations that act now are already seeing the results. Our client Efficio, for example, embedded structured data across its site, increasing AI citations by 245% and tripling conversions from AI-driven visitors within six months.
Your audiences are still asking questions.
The only question is - will your organisation be part of the answer?
take our AI READINESS Assessment
Is your marketing ready for the Age of Answers?
Take the AI Readiness Assessment for professional services marketers and get your personalised AI Readiness report and 13-page "Stay visible" playbook.
Answer 16 quick questions about your digital and content marketing initiatives to find out how visible your expertise is to AI, where the gaps are, and what to do next.
- It takes just 6 minutes to complete.
- It’s completely free.
OUR WORK